Paityn's POV:
Anthony quickly pulled the car over and turned to look at me. We got stuck in traffic a lot on the way over to Queens and because of that, we lost a couple of hours just sitting in the car. It's now dark outside and because of that, I couldn't really see his expression that well. The lights from the dash were the only thing glowing on his face.
"Did you ever open it? Do you know what was in it?" He asked me and I just shook my head.
"I didn't have a key," I told him.
"Where is it? It's obviously not in the apartment because trust me, they would have found it if it was there." He said to me and I just looked at him blankly.
"I don't remember what I did with it. I...I had it in my hands before the detectives showed up." I told him as I tried r
