As dinner continued, the conversation remained lively and light. The brothers laughed, shared stories, and made sure that Lily was enjoying every moment. But as the plates were cleared and dessert was being served, Theo’s expression turned serious. He glanced at his brothers, and the playful atmosphere began to shift as the others noticed his change in demeanor.
Theo cleared his throat and looked over at Nick. "There’s something I need to tell you all," he began, his tone grave. "Something that happened earlier today with Lily’s neighbor, Sam."
Immediately, the room grew quiet. Nick’s eyes narrowed, and the other brothers all leaned in, their expressions darkening. Lily’s own face reflected the tension, and she could feel the shift in energy as Theo continued.
"When Lily was packing up
