Charlotte hurriedly wanted to stand up and defend him when everyone here watched Samuel balefully. But Samuel stretched out his hand to stop her, shook his head and said with a smile, “You know, one who has a mind to beat his dog will easily find his stick. Austin’s words are nothing more than to ruin my reputation.” “Samuel, it’s all my fault.” Tears misted her eyes. She knew if she hadn’t celebrated her father’s birthday, Samuel wouldn’t have come with her, and naturally, he wouldn’t have been humiliated by these people. As Charlotte’s husband, he suddenly came here to celebrate Ethan’s birthday. Everyone could guess that Samuel wanted to turn to Johnson’s family. Samuel waved his hands slightly and did not say a word, just standing up and looking at Austin from afar.